Whose sword fight would be more likely to win, the best medieval knight or the best modern swordmaster?

Whose sword fight would be more likely to win, the best medieval knight or the best modern swordmaster?

Haaland knipst wieder! BVB besiegt Freiburg: Dortmund - Freiburg 4:0 | Bundesliga | DAZN Highlights

Previous questionIsn't it harmful to run in the morning on an empty stomach?
Next questionFriends advised me to start gambling at Fonbet, but it is illegal with us. Tell me, are there ways to bypass the blocking?

answers (3)

Answer 1
March, 2021

The best fighting technique is the survivor technique. A knight, if he is over 20 years old, has shown his art of surviving many times. The modern master of the sword NEVER survived in the conditions of sword fighting, corny there is no possibility. Secondly, if both participants are of the same age, then the knight learned from childhood, and the master of the sword, at best, from adolescence. The third is fencing technique. The knight's style is pure utilitarianism (hit and hit hard), while modern swordsmanship is overloaded with unnecessary complexity. And the tasks of the knight and the swordsman are different (because the art of swordsmanship appeared only in the late Middle Ages)

thus on the side of the knight experience, training and determination, on the side of the swordsman, technique and experience of generations. difficult to choose a winner

Answer 2
March, 2021

The question does not take into account a lot of nuances, which is why a reasonable answer is, in principle, impossible. For example - in what technique and with what weapon does a modern master fight? A lot depends on this.

Therefore, by my own arbitrariness, I introduce additional conditions.

The master and the knight possess one technique and one weapon. They fight. And before the fight, either both do not wear armor, or both do. In the first case, the knight loses nothing. He is taught from childhood to fight this way and that. But in the second case, the master can lose a lot if he does not feel like a fish in water in armor.

Let's go further: the conditions of the duel. If you are fighting for points with a bunch of restrictions, then it is unrealistic to predict the result. Although, most likely, the master has more chances (I don't think that the knights were engaged in such garbage as a duel "for points").

But if the fight is to death, the master can safely order a coffin for himself. After all, a knight is a professional assassin. This is a special attitude to the fight, taught to short from childhood and honed regularly in real, not training "meat grinders".

The Master simply cannot cope with the pressure of a warrior who is used to - and loves - to kill.

An important point: everything said in the last paragraph (about fighting to death) was confirmed to me by a person who has been fond of historical fencing for many years - in knightly armor and on real swords.

True, he is made a couple of additions:

1) real knights had competitions that were essentially close to our battles "for points" (so the chances of a modern master are also reduced here).

2) to align the initial chances of victory for both participants would have to:

A) either the medieval knight should be seriously fattened and treated (including from worms, vitamin deficiency, etc.). Otherwise, he will come out to a duel weakened in comparison with a modern master. The fact is that in the Middle Ages, nutrition - especially healthy, and even more so, fortified and high-calorie - was bad. Even the gentlemen of the knights. Plus + a bunch of chronic diseases in almost everyone. After all, medicine, in comparison with modern medicine, was generally - in a deep ... cave ...

B) either send a modern master to the Middle Ages before a fight, so that he weakened from poor nutrition, picked up sores and weakened. Thus, he became a knight on a par with the Middle Ages.

Answer 3
March, 2021

The best swordsman. Against a good swordsman with a sword, a knight in armor and with a sword is practically powerless, simply due to less mobility. The skater stabs the "armored" enemy in the slit of the armor while he is making a swing. Similar victories were described in fiction and historical literature, in fact, the very transition from armor and a heavy sword to much lighter swords and sabers (and the abandonment of armor armor) was simply due to their higher efficiency.

Related question

Fedor Emelianenko will fight Frank Mir in April 2018. Who has the best chance of winning?

Read more

What would it be like to be forever in space in good health and consciousness?

Read more

I work physical work. I don't go to the gym. I would like to build muscle, what kind of sports nutrition. to take for best effect (protein-casein)?

Read more

I Went on a 900 IQ Rampage in Among Us!

If there was a computer fighting game, but with the participation of deities of various religions, who would be stronger than the rest?

Read more

Without what was it easier to survive in the medieval world: without a hand or without an eye?

Read more

Hands do not grow (lag far behind). I would like to be curious, is it possible to swing only arms more than 2 times a week? P.s do at home (barbell / dumbbells).

Read more

What do you like to watch more boxing or mixed martial arts?

Read more

What shoes are best for parkour. Would it be nice if there was a combination of good adhesion and strength (so as not to step on the nail)?

Read more

Die Roten Bullen vermasseln Baums Debüt: RB Leipzig - Schalke 4:0 | Bundesliga | DAZN Highlights

Why is the winner of the regular season valued in football, while the league cup is a consolation, and in hockey, on the contrary: winning the Gagarin Cup or the Stanley Cup is much more prestigious?

Read more

When is the best time to exercise, morning or evening?

Read more

Why do some girls like to be strangled during sex or kissing?

Read more

Lost her virginity. After that, the sex was 3 more times, but I don't like it. I only feel the tremors. Girls, then everything will be ok?

Read more

Would you be ashamed to non-anonymously admit on the Internet that you have dandruff, you sweat a lot, or some other minor body problems?

Read more

Viererpack! Lewandowski sorgt für dramatisches Ende: FC Bayern - Hertha BSC 4:3 | Bundesliga | DAZN

What is the best way to run to keep fit: fast or slow?

Read more

Why does food fly under the beer like children go to school? Much more than usual

Read more

What would the world look like if the human retina perceived radiation from gamma to radio waves?

Read more

Where is the best place to buy vitamins? (At a pharmacy or sports nutrition store)

Read more

What is the best way to sleep - in panties or naked?

Read more

Ed Sheeran, Kygo, Avicii, Martin Garrix, The Chainsmokers, Dua Lipa Styles - Feeling Me

Is it possible at the age of 14 to learn how to dance ballroom dancing well, or should it be done only from an early age, like gymnastics?

Read more

My girlfriend is thin, she says that she would like a more "appetizing body" but eats very little + constant stress, studies, etc. What is your advice on how to help her?

Read more